Menu
Call
Contact
Blog
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube

Call for Free Consultation

Toll Free 866-769-0123

866-769-0123
Menu
Kaire & Heffernan
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Firm Overview
    • Mark Kaire
    • David R. Heffernan
  • Practice Areas
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Car Accidents
      • How Safe Is Your Miami Route?
    • Distracted Driving Accidents
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Negligent Security
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Personal Injury
    • Premises Liability
    • Stroke Malpractice
    • Swimming Pool Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Uber and Lyft Accidents
    • Workers Compensation
    • Wrongful Death
  • Results
  • Testimonials
  • Media
    • Podcasts
  • Hospital Safety Reports
    • Aventura Hospital
    • Baptist Hospital of Miami
    • Doctors Hospital
    • Kendall Regional Medical Center
    • Mount Sinai Medical Center
    • North Shore Medical Center
    • Palmetto General Hospital
    • South Miami Hospital
    • University of Miami Hospital
  • Medical Records
  • Video FAQ
  • Blog
  • Español
  • Contact Us
  • Menu Menu

  • Best Medical Malpractice Lawyers in Miami!
  • American Board of Trail Advocates
  • Best Lawyers
  • 9.6David Roy Heffernan
  • David R. Heffernan
    Rated by Super Lawyers


    loading ...
  • Million Dollar Advocates Form
  • Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Form
  • Florida Legal Elite
  • Top 100 Trial Lawyers
  • Top 100 Personal Injury Attorneys
left arrow right arrow

What You Tell Your Doctor Following An Accident Can Make Or Break Your Case

June 22, 2019/in Bike Accidents, Car Accidents /by Mark Kaire

In the world of Personal injury and medical malpractice, facts matter. A hidden word in thousands of pages of medical records can be a deciding factor. Words matter!!

A recent case from Florida’s 5th DCA, make it clear that information contained within medical records regarding how an accident happened is admissible. To the end, Cynthia Underwood was injured on July 11, 2010 when the motorcycle she was driving collided with a sport utility vehicle driven by Katherine Strong.

Mrs. Underwood sued Ms. Strong, alleging that Ms. Strong had negligently operated her vehicle, thereby causing the collision and severely injuring Mrs. Underwood. The case proceeded to trial solely on the issue of liability. The jury found Ms. Strong fifty percent at fault.

Ms. Strong appealed and argued that the trial court erred in refusing to admit a medical record containing a statement made by Mrs. Underwood to her treating physician concerning how the accident occurred. The 5th DCA agreed with Ms. Strong and remanded for a new trial on liability. Strong v. Underwood, 44 Fla. L. Weekly D1598c(Fla. 5th DCA 2019).

The issue at trial was liability for the accident, with each party alleging the other crossed the center line and caused the accident. It is obvious the jury did not know who to believe and thus split liability 50/50. At trial, Ms. Strong sought to admit a medical record from one of Mrs. Underwood’s treating physicians, Dr. Michael Cheatham. During a deposition, Dr. Cheatham testified that according to his medical record, he examined Mrs. Underwood the day after the accident. At that time, he recorded the following entry in the medical record:

Ms. Underwood is a 44-year-old white female who was the helmeted rider of a motorcycle that was involved in a crash yesterday. She states that one of the tires on her motorcycle blew, and she collided head-on with the SUV at an unknown rate of speed.

Dr. Cheatham testified that he would not normally write “ ‘she states’ unless a patient . . . verbalize[d] [the statement] to” him.

The trial court excluded the statement as inadmissible hearsay, finding the source of the statement was unknown. As a result, Dr. Cheatham did not testify at trial and neither the statement nor the medical record was introduced at trial.

Ms. Strong argued, and the 5th DCA agreed, that Mrs. Underwood’s statement should have been admissible as the admission of a party-opponent contained in a business record. She further argues the source of the statement was known because the medical record indicates the statement came from Mrs. Underwood.

Florida statute 90.803 sets forth exceptions to the Hearsay rule

Simply stated, medical records are admissible at trial. Likewise, a patient’s statements contained within medical records are admissible, provided the statements themselves fall under a separate hearsay exception. See, e.g., Otis Elevator Co. v. Youngerman, 636 So. 2d 166, 167 (Fla. 4th DCA 1994) (holding plaintiff’s statements in medical record admissible as statements made for purposes of medical diagnosis and treatment); Wilkinson v. Grover, 181 So. 2d 591, 593-94 (Fla. 3d DCA 1965) (holding statement in medical record admissible as admission by party-opponent).

As the 5th DCA stated; “The statement at issue here indicated the accident occurred after one of the tires on Mrs. Underwood’s motorcycle blew, causing her to collide with Ms. Strong’s vehicle. Ms. Strong sought to use this statement against Mrs. Underwood at trial. Accordingly, as it was Mrs. Underwood’s statement and offered against her, it falls within the hearsay exception set forth at section 90.803(18)(a), Florida Statutes.”

90.803 Hearsay exceptions; availability of declarant immaterial.—The provision of s. 90.802to the contrary notwithstanding, the following are not inadmissible as evidence, even though the declarant is available as a witness:

18) ADMISSIONS.—A statement that is offered against a party and is:

(a) The party’s own statement in either an individual or a representative capacity;

The key portion from the ruling is the fact that the medical record itself states the source of the statement was Mrs. Underwood.

She states that one of the tires on her motorcycle blew . . . .”

Always speak with a lawyer as early on in the case as possible. In this case, a gratuitous statement that had no bearing on the injuries, treatment, or medical diagnosis had significant repercussions. Another important tool is to get the medical records as quickly as possible. We request and review medical records immediately. If we believe there is an error in the medical records, we can ask to doctor to review his records and draft an addendum. This is much easier to accomplish while the doctor may still have an independent recollection of the patient and the subject conversation.

Mark Kaire
Mark Kaire

Mark Kaire has been practicing law in Miami for nearly 30 years. He is dedicated to helping the injured people of Miami receive compensation. Mr. Kaire has been blogging on Miami’s legal issues for many years.

Share this entry
  • Share on WhatsApp

Do you have a case?

Get your question answered

"*" indicates required fields

Recent Posts

  • Can You Sue a Hotel for Negligent Security?
  • Determining Fault in a Rideshare Accident
  • Hit-and-Run Accidents: What to Do If You Have Been Injured?
  • Top 8 Causes of Motorcycle Accident Cases in Miami
  • A Miami Birth Injury Attorney is Essential to a Successful Case

Categories

  • Bike Accidents
  • Birth Injury
  • Car Accidents
  • Construction Accidents
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Negligent Security
  • News
  • Nursing Home Abuse
  • Personal Injury
  • Podcasts
  • Workers Compensation

Interesting links

Here are some interesting links for you! Enjoy your stay :)
  • Firm Overview
  • Practice Areas
  • Results
  • Testimonials
  • Video FAQ
  • Blog
  • Español
  • Contact Us
Copyright © 1999 - 2023. Kaire & Heffernan - All Rights Reserved. | Sitemap | Disclaimer
 
Best Lawyers - Lawyer Logo
Fall Protection Training Near MiamiFall Protection Training Near MiamiTiger Woods Dismissed from Wrongful Death Suit